Monday, February 11, 2008

Honor 3-3

1.My answer to last week’s question is that it is just a way to define what kind of group a person is in. If a person is asked how they know someone, then they can answer through band or tennis. By splitting up one’s community, a person can define and explain why a person is in his/ her community.
2.This week we discussed Case study 1-1. It was interesting to look at how many people knew about cheating but just didn’t do anything about it. We all say the honor code is important but none of us report a violation. I also went farther into the honor code search and found that schools in other countries feel that the honor code is purely an American innovation. If so, did we create a problem by making an honor code? Or, were we simply looking for a solution to a problem already faced by students? I really don’t know, but I think the honor code is an ideal like the Golden Rule. It’s nice but its not practical and neither are the punishments for offenses. One problem I see with it is how can you teach a person to be honorable? Isn’t that a nurture thing, and if your raised in deception, why would you feel bad about deceiving. The honor code asks everyone to look at honor in the same way when it is not looked at in the same way. I know people who view honor as sticking up and defending their race no matter what. To them it’s a matter of the honor of the group even if it means the lowest type of deception and no honor for themselves. Of course, we are dealing with honor in schools, but if school doesn’t matter, then why should personal honor in a school. This would be as far as I have gotten in thinking about this topic. Frankly, I don’t know what perspective of honor is more important.
3.My question for next week is who wins the Virginia Primary?

No comments: