1. Although Al Gore did not win the 2000 election, he has stayed extremely active. He is the Chairman of Current TV, Generation Investment Management, and Alliance for Climate Protection. He is also on the board of Apple Inc. and an advisor to Google’s senior Management. He also starred in a documentary about global climate change called “The Inconvenient Truth”. Due to his global climate awareness efforts, Al Gore recently received the Nobel Prize. Maybe not winning the 2000 election was a good thing.
2.This week our teacher had us look at opposing and supporting viewpoints to Michael Moore’s film, Fahrenheit 9-11. The reports were by David Kopel and Wade. Kopel wrote an article rebutting almost all of Michael Moore’s film and pointing out all of the fallacies. Wade wrote an article about all of Kopel’s fallacies. If there ever is a reply about Wade’s article, I think we may be able to get down to the real scraps of truth in the film. I feel as if Michael Moore assumes a lot about connections, or hopes people will believe him if he puts a lot of information out there. Honestly, it is very easy to believe him, and say yes it makes sense. But until the person goes out to find out what is true and what is not, the viewer has not learned anything. Michael Moore knows that, and the documentaries are not educational until analyzed. This is why I am glad I have seen the documentary. I have learned new names and figures, and I have been able to make an original opinion about what went on.
3. For next week my question is, what recent elections have occurred outside of the US that are controversial?
Sunday, December 9, 2007
Monday, December 3, 2007
Extra! Extra! Read All About It!
1. Yes there are plenty of leaders who have ties with this region. Many politicians who were business men had to, at one point or another deal with these countries. One example would be our current President. Before taking office, he was a business man and he dealt in oil. Of course, as the Middle East has a plethora of oil, he had many discussions in business dealings. Money and politics, in my opinion, should be two different things. Unfortunately, they are not, and to get into political office, a candidate must have a small fortune with which to campaign with because campaigns are expensive.
2. This week in class we analyzed the turnouts of the 2000 election. We looked at a timetable of what time different major news stations reported and retracted the winner. The results were pretty confusing and interesting. Many news stations, including FOX, reported Gore as the winner. As the night dragged on, retractions were made, and FOX sent off the alarm that Bush won. No one knew for sure and I doubt anyone will know because there was never an official recount. I do believe, however, that had Gore not been President of the Senate at the tome he may have petitioned for the recount. Because he held the office, it would have created a fight between the branches of government, and Gore knew better than to stain the end of a Democratic Presidency with a mark like that. What is surprising is that Gore will not run again. There are a lot more candidates, but he has a shot. He is popular amongst key states and he has a lot of experience. Also, he has stayed politically active by helping the environment and receiving the Nobel Prize. As for the 2000 election, there will always be controversy over the fact that the most Democratic nation in the world has trouble keeping track of its votes.
3. My question for next week is what else has Al Gore done while out of office?
2. This week in class we analyzed the turnouts of the 2000 election. We looked at a timetable of what time different major news stations reported and retracted the winner. The results were pretty confusing and interesting. Many news stations, including FOX, reported Gore as the winner. As the night dragged on, retractions were made, and FOX sent off the alarm that Bush won. No one knew for sure and I doubt anyone will know because there was never an official recount. I do believe, however, that had Gore not been President of the Senate at the tome he may have petitioned for the recount. Because he held the office, it would have created a fight between the branches of government, and Gore knew better than to stain the end of a Democratic Presidency with a mark like that. What is surprising is that Gore will not run again. There are a lot more candidates, but he has a shot. He is popular amongst key states and he has a lot of experience. Also, he has stayed politically active by helping the environment and receiving the Nobel Prize. As for the 2000 election, there will always be controversy over the fact that the most Democratic nation in the world has trouble keeping track of its votes.
3. My question for next week is what else has Al Gore done while out of office?
Tuesday, November 27, 2007
Bleep Bleep Bleep...You can't say that! 2-3
1. Censorship can effect what is reported in a military government. For example, a country under a dictatorship can have the editors forced into cutting out articles that are printed against the government. It basically is a way for the government to control how much and what kind of information is given out to the general public.
2. This week, we only had class one day, but we began to lay the groundwork for watching Fahrenheit 9/11. WE basically discussed the connections between different Middle Eastern Countries and fundamentalist groups. The relationships are complicated and they change a lot over time. I remember reading about how the US basically set the spark for al-Qaeda to be formed, but now they are public enemy number 1.I have a feeling that the war and relations over in the region will be complicated for a long time. The US finds itself in a sticky position because it has to remain allies with many countries while trying to get them to conceded territory or make allies with other countries or groups they have had problems with for many years. I also wonder if the Muslim population skyrockets in the US, if they will be allowed to circulate their own newspapers nationwide. Imagine if the entire nation was convinced that Osama and al-Qaeda was right the entire time. What would happen to our allies? Would they drop like flies or multiply? Would Muslim fundamentalists even be allowed to have their own newspaper? It is out there, but there is merit to it. Freedom of press does mean freedom for all press, so why not?
3. My question for next week is is there is a political leader with ties to the region going way back?
2. This week, we only had class one day, but we began to lay the groundwork for watching Fahrenheit 9/11. WE basically discussed the connections between different Middle Eastern Countries and fundamentalist groups. The relationships are complicated and they change a lot over time. I remember reading about how the US basically set the spark for al-Qaeda to be formed, but now they are public enemy number 1.I have a feeling that the war and relations over in the region will be complicated for a long time. The US finds itself in a sticky position because it has to remain allies with many countries while trying to get them to conceded territory or make allies with other countries or groups they have had problems with for many years. I also wonder if the Muslim population skyrockets in the US, if they will be allowed to circulate their own newspapers nationwide. Imagine if the entire nation was convinced that Osama and al-Qaeda was right the entire time. What would happen to our allies? Would they drop like flies or multiply? Would Muslim fundamentalists even be allowed to have their own newspaper? It is out there, but there is merit to it. Freedom of press does mean freedom for all press, so why not?
3. My question for next week is is there is a political leader with ties to the region going way back?
Saturday, November 17, 2007
What can I say, I am from the US of A 2-2
1. The freedom of speech is part of the First Amendment in the U.S. Constitution. It provides for the freedom of voice and expressing one’s opinion verbally without persecution. I feel that this is a sacred part of the culture of the United States. It allows for the entire country to express its opinion.
2. This week the discussions mainly focused on filters and their effect on people when they process information. One of the individuals in the documentary blatantly states that there is no such thing as an objective opinion. I believe this is true because everything depends on who it is heard from. To test this class did a project on perspective in newspapers. I used www. Refdesk.com to look up newspapers in different country. I used what was going on in Pakistan as my topic to compare. My countries were the U.S., Pakistan, and Afghanistan. What I found was very neat. Pakistan and the US were on the same page whereas Afghanistan supported Musharaff. For countries in such close proximity o not have the same opinion is very incredible to me. Pakistan and Afghanistan not only share a common Asian name, but they also have the same religion and culture. This website is probably something I will keep looking into.
3. For next week my question is: how does censorship effect what is reported?
2. This week the discussions mainly focused on filters and their effect on people when they process information. One of the individuals in the documentary blatantly states that there is no such thing as an objective opinion. I believe this is true because everything depends on who it is heard from. To test this class did a project on perspective in newspapers. I used www. Refdesk.com to look up newspapers in different country. I used what was going on in Pakistan as my topic to compare. My countries were the U.S., Pakistan, and Afghanistan. What I found was very neat. Pakistan and the US were on the same page whereas Afghanistan supported Musharaff. For countries in such close proximity o not have the same opinion is very incredible to me. Pakistan and Afghanistan not only share a common Asian name, but they also have the same religion and culture. This website is probably something I will keep looking into.
3. For next week my question is: how does censorship effect what is reported?
Sunday, November 11, 2007
DO YOU HEAR THE WORDS COMIN' OUT OF MY MOUTH? 2-1
1. Other factors to consider at the national level are getting the word out there about a campaign. Also, national election candidates usually have to find voters that don’t vote and get them to vote for the respective candidate. The more voters a candidate has the more likely it is that they will win. Another part of a national campaign is dealing with issues that apply and appeal to voters across the nation. In a state election, the issues can be very similar across the board, but in a national campaign, the candidate must be respectable in every corner of the nation.
2. This week in class we started the documentary “This Divided State”, which deals with Michael Moore coming to visit Utah Valley State College. Prior to Michael Moore’s arrival, the school and the surrounding community square off. The community around the campus is very conservative and feels that Michael Moore should not be allowed to “corrupt the minds of America”. The college, however, feels that students should be exposed to all thoughts even the ones they disagree with the most. I personally agree with the college. The freedom of speech part in the first amendment does not protect someone from speech. This distinction is very important. Also, it is up to the students who are now legally adults as to what they do and do not want to hear. Exposure to different cultures and opinions is vital to a young mind. These differences help each individual to develop their own thoughts.
3. Next week I will answer: what the freedom is the freedom of speech?
2. This week in class we started the documentary “This Divided State”, which deals with Michael Moore coming to visit Utah Valley State College. Prior to Michael Moore’s arrival, the school and the surrounding community square off. The community around the campus is very conservative and feels that Michael Moore should not be allowed to “corrupt the minds of America”. The college, however, feels that students should be exposed to all thoughts even the ones they disagree with the most. I personally agree with the college. The freedom of speech part in the first amendment does not protect someone from speech. This distinction is very important. Also, it is up to the students who are now legally adults as to what they do and do not want to hear. Exposure to different cultures and opinions is vital to a young mind. These differences help each individual to develop their own thoughts.
3. Next week I will answer: what the freedom is the freedom of speech?
Thursday, November 8, 2007
Vote For Me!! 1-8
1. A scandal, if proven wrong and denied by the accused party can be helpful to the candidate. It proves the conviction of a candidate because he/she does not back down from public disapproval.
2. This week, the class mainly focused on the Virginia elections. The number of positions with only one candidate running was appalling. There is a two-party system for a reason!! In the end, however, these positions were filled by very respectable people. Virginia is known for leaning to the conservative side, and this election was no different. Most every office was filled by a Republican. The issues of this campaign included property taxes and the new Meadowville Technology Park. In almost the 75% of the cases the candidate chosen was the incumbent. When listening to the students in my class, I realized that this is what an education is for. We will grow up and have to make these decisions. It’s better to know where to look for information earlier on in life, so I am glad we did this exercise. I am now a more informed citizen than my dad. Good for me and the other in my class because it will help in the future even if I can’t vote now.
3. For next week’s journal I ask myself what other factors play into elections at the national level.
2. This week, the class mainly focused on the Virginia elections. The number of positions with only one candidate running was appalling. There is a two-party system for a reason!! In the end, however, these positions were filled by very respectable people. Virginia is known for leaning to the conservative side, and this election was no different. Most every office was filled by a Republican. The issues of this campaign included property taxes and the new Meadowville Technology Park. In almost the 75% of the cases the candidate chosen was the incumbent. When listening to the students in my class, I realized that this is what an education is for. We will grow up and have to make these decisions. It’s better to know where to look for information earlier on in life, so I am glad we did this exercise. I am now a more informed citizen than my dad. Good for me and the other in my class because it will help in the future even if I can’t vote now.
3. For next week’s journal I ask myself what other factors play into elections at the national level.
Tuesday, October 30, 2007
Do you remember me? 1-7
1. In my opinion and experience, a bad mouth campaign is bad in many aspects. First, it makes the voter think about the other candidate. Second, the voter may think that the candidate badmouthing doesn’t actually have a platform. Third, this kind of campaigning is essentially blaming other people without showing accountability or responsibility for the job at hand. A historical example may be the election of 1800. In this election, the federalists tried vehemently to make Thomas Jefferson look bad. In the end, they lost because all the Electoral College could remember about the Federalists was badmouth campaigning. It seems silly, but first impressions, especially in the political arena, count for a lot.
2. This week we watched the CNN Youtube debate online. This debate is definitely the most interesting I have ever seen, even though I am no expert. The candidates really had to know the issues. I could literally pick out when the candidate was simply using vague language to answer a question. In this setting, it is not the quantity of questions answered, but the quality of responses given. The debate was also extremely entertaining. Viewers could see candidates’ campaign commercials. These commercials were one way to check that the candidates were consistently answering the same way on issues. Another key factor in the success of this type of debate was letting people get to see the candidates think on their feet. It is certainly no easy task, and when President, he or she will be faced with tough situations. Not only do the candidates have to think but they have to answer eloquently. They must give a response that is clear. The candidates most lacking in this field would have to be Kucinich and Gravel. They either need speech classes or coaches, but either way they need to be out of the race. Barack Obama had the most control over his speech. John Edwards flinched a lot, showing nervousness and second guessing. He is often portrayed as charming, but in this debate he was simply gasping for air. Hillary Clinton certainly addressed the people in the video, but not the question in the video. Her answers were filled with fluffed up language like “serious coercive democracy”. That means nothing to me. Either give me a plan that works or don’t answer the question. For the res of the candidates, I couldn’t remember them, so that is definitely I bad thing.
3. My question for next week is: can scandals be helpful in a campaign?
2. This week we watched the CNN Youtube debate online. This debate is definitely the most interesting I have ever seen, even though I am no expert. The candidates really had to know the issues. I could literally pick out when the candidate was simply using vague language to answer a question. In this setting, it is not the quantity of questions answered, but the quality of responses given. The debate was also extremely entertaining. Viewers could see candidates’ campaign commercials. These commercials were one way to check that the candidates were consistently answering the same way on issues. Another key factor in the success of this type of debate was letting people get to see the candidates think on their feet. It is certainly no easy task, and when President, he or she will be faced with tough situations. Not only do the candidates have to think but they have to answer eloquently. They must give a response that is clear. The candidates most lacking in this field would have to be Kucinich and Gravel. They either need speech classes or coaches, but either way they need to be out of the race. Barack Obama had the most control over his speech. John Edwards flinched a lot, showing nervousness and second guessing. He is often portrayed as charming, but in this debate he was simply gasping for air. Hillary Clinton certainly addressed the people in the video, but not the question in the video. Her answers were filled with fluffed up language like “serious coercive democracy”. That means nothing to me. Either give me a plan that works or don’t answer the question. For the res of the candidates, I couldn’t remember them, so that is definitely I bad thing.
3. My question for next week is: can scandals be helpful in a campaign?
Saturday, October 20, 2007
Campaigns Galore 1-6
1. To answer my question from last week, techniques in media are applied in campaigns by way of propaganda. For example, during the Reagan Campaign, photographers took pictures of the to-be President in many different settlings like on a horse, behind a desk, etc. In every situation, Mr. Reagan looked completely comfortable. Basically, people in different regions of America felt that they could relate to him. Media techniques are also used in campaign commercials. In the very last election, both candidates tried to slander the other. The commercials portrayed the candidates as liars, but they only provided half of the information. Our imaginations were given freedom to make up the rest. So basically campaigns allow the people to “see what they want to see” with the information we are given.
2. This week we watched the senatorial election of 1994 unfold. The main candidates are Oliver North and Chuck Robb. There is a lot of dirty campaigning going on. Each side is producing commercials about how untrustworthy the other candidate is. The movie provides a lot of insight into how the campaigning process works. For example, Oliver North’s analyst talks about how Ollie needs fill the hole when Chuck steps down. Also, they talk about how people will be convinced of his moral rectitude. The analysts also place him in different areas of Virginia throughout the movie in an almost “Reaganesque” campaigning. It is really difficult to detect a definite bias in this movie. The main focus is on North’s campaign, but there is still footage of Chuck Robb’s campaign. Also, this movie really does not use voice over’s like Michael Moore to sway opinion. So far, I think it has a slightly conservative bas as all of the references to past successful campaigns have been conservative. There is still more to be seen, so I will find out soon.
3. My question for next week is whether or not a bad mouth campaign is really worth it?
2. This week we watched the senatorial election of 1994 unfold. The main candidates are Oliver North and Chuck Robb. There is a lot of dirty campaigning going on. Each side is producing commercials about how untrustworthy the other candidate is. The movie provides a lot of insight into how the campaigning process works. For example, Oliver North’s analyst talks about how Ollie needs fill the hole when Chuck steps down. Also, they talk about how people will be convinced of his moral rectitude. The analysts also place him in different areas of Virginia throughout the movie in an almost “Reaganesque” campaigning. It is really difficult to detect a definite bias in this movie. The main focus is on North’s campaign, but there is still footage of Chuck Robb’s campaign. Also, this movie really does not use voice over’s like Michael Moore to sway opinion. So far, I think it has a slightly conservative bas as all of the references to past successful campaigns have been conservative. There is still more to be seen, so I will find out soon.
3. My question for next week is whether or not a bad mouth campaign is really worth it?
Monday, October 15, 2007
The Opinionated FOX 1-5
1. My question last week was where else could I find media techniques used. After going more in depth in class, I found out that media “tweaking” can be found in Reality TV. For example, ever wonder why reality TV shows show the high tensity moments and not the times when people are brushing their teeth. Well, they need ratings. They create tension through cutting, and by staging certain events. This way people remain interested for the entire half-hour or hour they are watching.
2. Another location that I can find media techniques is on the news. This week the class watched Rubert Murdoch’s War on the Media, or something to that end. The entire movie/documentary was on how FOX news station is extremely slanted towards the right wing. The documentary picked out scenes in which FOX was at its worst and the feeling that I got was that FOX wants to change everyone’s view point to that of conservative. Whereas that may or may not be the case. I personally never watch FOX, and I do think it is too conservative. However, this is not cause for me to go out and protest journalism or lack thereof. People who want to watch FOX can watch FOX and people who don’t want to don’t have to. This is the beauty of choice and a myriad of locations to get the news from. This day in age it is difficult to distinguish between news and commentary. How does one decide whether or not what is given is unbiased? Well for one, the news will never be unbiased. The station will always have to make a decision as to what and how it reports. Also news should never be reported without a bias. By giving a bias, the viewer can form their opinion and decide if they believe it or not. It also provides a field for questioning what goes on in the world.
3. My question for next week is how these techniques are used in campaigns.
2. Another location that I can find media techniques is on the news. This week the class watched Rubert Murdoch’s War on the Media, or something to that end. The entire movie/documentary was on how FOX news station is extremely slanted towards the right wing. The documentary picked out scenes in which FOX was at its worst and the feeling that I got was that FOX wants to change everyone’s view point to that of conservative. Whereas that may or may not be the case. I personally never watch FOX, and I do think it is too conservative. However, this is not cause for me to go out and protest journalism or lack thereof. People who want to watch FOX can watch FOX and people who don’t want to don’t have to. This is the beauty of choice and a myriad of locations to get the news from. This day in age it is difficult to distinguish between news and commentary. How does one decide whether or not what is given is unbiased? Well for one, the news will never be unbiased. The station will always have to make a decision as to what and how it reports. Also news should never be reported without a bias. By giving a bias, the viewer can form their opinion and decide if they believe it or not. It also provides a field for questioning what goes on in the world.
3. My question for next week is how these techniques are used in campaigns.
Sunday, October 7, 2007
Why Bowling?
1. The bombing in Sudan was based on little evidence. The U.S. knew that the factory was shipping to Iraq and because Osama bin Laden had lived there for a few years, they (the U.S.) assumed that the owner had ties with bin Laden. Another important piece of information to remember is that the U.S. bombed other places that same day including Afghanistan Insurgent camps. In the end, only one person died in the bombing. However, because the bombing is placed in the middle of the montage, and Michael Moore states that the U.S. killed so many people, it is assumed that many people, including innocent factory workers were killed.
2. This week, the class went to the very end of the movie “Bowling for Columbine”. We discussed why the movie was called bowling for Columbine and how everything ties into the movie. My ideas about this are that the bowling theme was used because it is thought that the shooters in the Columbine shooting went bowling beforehand. Michael Moore then uses bowling as a reason for the shooting. To go along with this he shows other reasons such as Marilyn Manson for the shooting as far as influences. Other reasons for the title include trying to make ten points because there may have been ten reasons for the making of the film. The only thing that really confused me in the whole movie was Michael Moore bowling at the very end. He goes through this whole movie bringing up reasons for shootings, one of them bowling, and hen he goes bowling. I think it makes him look bad because I automatically think hat he wants to shoot someone.
3. My question for next week is where else can I find media techniques used?
2. This week, the class went to the very end of the movie “Bowling for Columbine”. We discussed why the movie was called bowling for Columbine and how everything ties into the movie. My ideas about this are that the bowling theme was used because it is thought that the shooters in the Columbine shooting went bowling beforehand. Michael Moore then uses bowling as a reason for the shooting. To go along with this he shows other reasons such as Marilyn Manson for the shooting as far as influences. Other reasons for the title include trying to make ten points because there may have been ten reasons for the making of the film. The only thing that really confused me in the whole movie was Michael Moore bowling at the very end. He goes through this whole movie bringing up reasons for shootings, one of them bowling, and hen he goes bowling. I think it makes him look bad because I automatically think hat he wants to shoot someone.
3. My question for next week is where else can I find media techniques used?
Saturday, September 29, 2007
Michael Moore: Killer Bees and the NRA 1-3
1. Let’s just say that Michael Moore is very tricky in editing. He cuts and pastes a documentary together. By getting the viewer to feel one emotion, he then gives that viewer a person or an organization to dispel the hate. For example, in Bowling for Columbine, Michael Moore puts all of these awful images from Columbine, and the viewer is upset and angry that it happened. He then cuts into a speech given by Mr. Heston of the NRA. I immediately responded to this technique. I hated the NRA during the next five minutes. It was then explained what was going on. I realized that it wasn’t the NRA that was insensitive, but Michael Moore himself. The NRA didn’t put those images in front of me; Michael Moore made that movie and edited it to influence people through their images. In one way, it is genius, in another, it is sick and t is a horrible way to influence people.
2. This week in class, we went into further depth on the movie “Bowling For Columbine”. The points that stuck out as well as disgusted me were The Wonderful World Montage” and the reference of blaming black people for crimes and tying the Killer Africanized bees. The wonderful world montage is wrong in many different ways. For one, America is not the World. If he thinks that, then he’s got more problems then I care to know. Secondly, Michael Moore fails to give all sides of the story. He says that the "Clinton bombs 'weapons factory' in Sudan. Factory turns out to be making asprin", but what were the circumstances? Why did it happen, and how long of a period did it cover. Who else was involved? The part that most disturbed me was his reference to Africanized bees and black people being blamed for crimes. In this part it is as if h is saying humans and bees have the same behavioral pattern and that government officials as well as police officers use this to arrest people. For example, the movie includes an interview with a bee farmer, who states that Africanized bees are “very aggressive” and they kill people. The same farmer breeds European bees that are “much more calm and do not attack”. How sick is it to tie in killer bees with black people. This of course is my interpretation of these two parts. There may be more to it then I mentioned.
3. My question for next week is to answer the questions I outlined above about the bombing in Sudan.
2. This week in class, we went into further depth on the movie “Bowling For Columbine”. The points that stuck out as well as disgusted me were The Wonderful World Montage” and the reference of blaming black people for crimes and tying the Killer Africanized bees. The wonderful world montage is wrong in many different ways. For one, America is not the World. If he thinks that, then he’s got more problems then I care to know. Secondly, Michael Moore fails to give all sides of the story. He says that the "Clinton bombs 'weapons factory' in Sudan. Factory turns out to be making asprin", but what were the circumstances? Why did it happen, and how long of a period did it cover. Who else was involved? The part that most disturbed me was his reference to Africanized bees and black people being blamed for crimes. In this part it is as if h is saying humans and bees have the same behavioral pattern and that government officials as well as police officers use this to arrest people. For example, the movie includes an interview with a bee farmer, who states that Africanized bees are “very aggressive” and they kill people. The same farmer breeds European bees that are “much more calm and do not attack”. How sick is it to tie in killer bees with black people. This of course is my interpretation of these two parts. There may be more to it then I mentioned.
3. My question for next week is to answer the questions I outlined above about the bombing in Sudan.
Sunday, September 23, 2007
The Complex Question
1-2
1. To answer last week's question: I have found through my research that companies select target groups. Each group has certain things that are important to them. For example, teenagers are interested in flashy, new trends and fads. Because of this, advertising by companies usually includes an endorsement from someone famous, or something that looks "cool." Most teenagers want to be exactly like the popular kids. This in turn helps the companies because as long as teenagers want to be popular and buy, the companies will stay in business.
2. This week in class we discussed Logical Fallacy. The fallacy I was assigned was that of the complex question. I see the complex question in debates, TV interviews, and campaign speeches as an example of rhetoric. The complex question serves to make the responder look bad either way they answer. I think it is a great way to make a point, but it is also something to look for. The question traps a person, and unless the question is answered properly, it could potentially hurt a person's reputation and standing. The viewer should also look for these. It helps to decide whether the question is fair. For example, I was watching Glenn Beck on CNN and he was interviewing a known pedophile in Massachusetts. The questions he asked the man were so pointed at making the person look bad, I couldn't tell who was the bad guy. In short, looking for fallacies such as the complex question is important.
3. How does Michael Moore's editing technique make the viewer react based upon the form of the interview?
1. To answer last week's question: I have found through my research that companies select target groups. Each group has certain things that are important to them. For example, teenagers are interested in flashy, new trends and fads. Because of this, advertising by companies usually includes an endorsement from someone famous, or something that looks "cool." Most teenagers want to be exactly like the popular kids. This in turn helps the companies because as long as teenagers want to be popular and buy, the companies will stay in business.
2. This week in class we discussed Logical Fallacy. The fallacy I was assigned was that of the complex question. I see the complex question in debates, TV interviews, and campaign speeches as an example of rhetoric. The complex question serves to make the responder look bad either way they answer. I think it is a great way to make a point, but it is also something to look for. The question traps a person, and unless the question is answered properly, it could potentially hurt a person's reputation and standing. The viewer should also look for these. It helps to decide whether the question is fair. For example, I was watching Glenn Beck on CNN and he was interviewing a known pedophile in Massachusetts. The questions he asked the man were so pointed at making the person look bad, I couldn't tell who was the bad guy. In short, looking for fallacies such as the complex question is important.
3. How does Michael Moore's editing technique make the viewer react based upon the form of the interview?
Monday, September 17, 2007
Loaded Language: Powerful or Fallacy?
1. Unfortunately, I do not have a question to answer this week, but I will next week.
2. This week the topic of choice was on Loaded Language. I personally feel that loaded language is moving and persuasive, but it is different for each individual person. I look at fallacy in loaded language as fake propaganda. For example, when we had student elections in the fifth grade, kids would literally promise soda fountains and a water park. These promises were not true, but they were effective in getting people to vote for the person. The same is true in high school. Now, however, the fake promises are kept to minimum. What matters most to high schoolers includes dances specifically prom. Every campaign speech included something about making prom the best it has ever been. Other than this one promise, most people ride on the popularity card. Can they get people to vote for them through candy bribes, stickers, and other flashy objects. Loaded language in the political world is another step up. This is due to the fact that people have to be “politically correct”. I used to care, but now I think why it matters what you call it, it still exists. For example, Shakespeare once said “A rose by any other name would smell as sweet.” Hey as long as it is sweet, I don’t care what it is called. The point is to make people see either bad or good images. When I think nationalism, I think Red, white, and blue. I think cheering in the streets, and all other symbols of loyalty to one’s country. When I think gang, I think of people getting shot, and random fights on the street. The truth of the matter is that everyone comes with their own baggage and predisposition, so loaded language is not fallacy or powerful. The words are simple black on white. It is up to the individual as to what colors and images fill the lines.
3. My question to answer for next week is: What are the natural predisposition companies have on why and how consumers buy? And with this information, how do they market their product?
2. This week the topic of choice was on Loaded Language. I personally feel that loaded language is moving and persuasive, but it is different for each individual person. I look at fallacy in loaded language as fake propaganda. For example, when we had student elections in the fifth grade, kids would literally promise soda fountains and a water park. These promises were not true, but they were effective in getting people to vote for the person. The same is true in high school. Now, however, the fake promises are kept to minimum. What matters most to high schoolers includes dances specifically prom. Every campaign speech included something about making prom the best it has ever been. Other than this one promise, most people ride on the popularity card. Can they get people to vote for them through candy bribes, stickers, and other flashy objects. Loaded language in the political world is another step up. This is due to the fact that people have to be “politically correct”. I used to care, but now I think why it matters what you call it, it still exists. For example, Shakespeare once said “A rose by any other name would smell as sweet.” Hey as long as it is sweet, I don’t care what it is called. The point is to make people see either bad or good images. When I think nationalism, I think Red, white, and blue. I think cheering in the streets, and all other symbols of loyalty to one’s country. When I think gang, I think of people getting shot, and random fights on the street. The truth of the matter is that everyone comes with their own baggage and predisposition, so loaded language is not fallacy or powerful. The words are simple black on white. It is up to the individual as to what colors and images fill the lines.
3. My question to answer for next week is: What are the natural predisposition companies have on why and how consumers buy? And with this information, how do they market their product?
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)