1. Let’s just say that Michael Moore is very tricky in editing. He cuts and pastes a documentary together. By getting the viewer to feel one emotion, he then gives that viewer a person or an organization to dispel the hate. For example, in Bowling for Columbine, Michael Moore puts all of these awful images from Columbine, and the viewer is upset and angry that it happened. He then cuts into a speech given by Mr. Heston of the NRA. I immediately responded to this technique. I hated the NRA during the next five minutes. It was then explained what was going on. I realized that it wasn’t the NRA that was insensitive, but Michael Moore himself. The NRA didn’t put those images in front of me; Michael Moore made that movie and edited it to influence people through their images. In one way, it is genius, in another, it is sick and t is a horrible way to influence people.
2. This week in class, we went into further depth on the movie “Bowling For Columbine”. The points that stuck out as well as disgusted me were The Wonderful World Montage” and the reference of blaming black people for crimes and tying the Killer Africanized bees. The wonderful world montage is wrong in many different ways. For one, America is not the World. If he thinks that, then he’s got more problems then I care to know. Secondly, Michael Moore fails to give all sides of the story. He says that the "Clinton bombs 'weapons factory' in Sudan. Factory turns out to be making asprin", but what were the circumstances? Why did it happen, and how long of a period did it cover. Who else was involved? The part that most disturbed me was his reference to Africanized bees and black people being blamed for crimes. In this part it is as if h is saying humans and bees have the same behavioral pattern and that government officials as well as police officers use this to arrest people. For example, the movie includes an interview with a bee farmer, who states that Africanized bees are “very aggressive” and they kill people. The same farmer breeds European bees that are “much more calm and do not attack”. How sick is it to tie in killer bees with black people. This of course is my interpretation of these two parts. There may be more to it then I mentioned.
3. My question for next week is to answer the questions I outlined above about the bombing in Sudan.
Saturday, September 29, 2007
Sunday, September 23, 2007
The Complex Question
1-2
1. To answer last week's question: I have found through my research that companies select target groups. Each group has certain things that are important to them. For example, teenagers are interested in flashy, new trends and fads. Because of this, advertising by companies usually includes an endorsement from someone famous, or something that looks "cool." Most teenagers want to be exactly like the popular kids. This in turn helps the companies because as long as teenagers want to be popular and buy, the companies will stay in business.
2. This week in class we discussed Logical Fallacy. The fallacy I was assigned was that of the complex question. I see the complex question in debates, TV interviews, and campaign speeches as an example of rhetoric. The complex question serves to make the responder look bad either way they answer. I think it is a great way to make a point, but it is also something to look for. The question traps a person, and unless the question is answered properly, it could potentially hurt a person's reputation and standing. The viewer should also look for these. It helps to decide whether the question is fair. For example, I was watching Glenn Beck on CNN and he was interviewing a known pedophile in Massachusetts. The questions he asked the man were so pointed at making the person look bad, I couldn't tell who was the bad guy. In short, looking for fallacies such as the complex question is important.
3. How does Michael Moore's editing technique make the viewer react based upon the form of the interview?
1. To answer last week's question: I have found through my research that companies select target groups. Each group has certain things that are important to them. For example, teenagers are interested in flashy, new trends and fads. Because of this, advertising by companies usually includes an endorsement from someone famous, or something that looks "cool." Most teenagers want to be exactly like the popular kids. This in turn helps the companies because as long as teenagers want to be popular and buy, the companies will stay in business.
2. This week in class we discussed Logical Fallacy. The fallacy I was assigned was that of the complex question. I see the complex question in debates, TV interviews, and campaign speeches as an example of rhetoric. The complex question serves to make the responder look bad either way they answer. I think it is a great way to make a point, but it is also something to look for. The question traps a person, and unless the question is answered properly, it could potentially hurt a person's reputation and standing. The viewer should also look for these. It helps to decide whether the question is fair. For example, I was watching Glenn Beck on CNN and he was interviewing a known pedophile in Massachusetts. The questions he asked the man were so pointed at making the person look bad, I couldn't tell who was the bad guy. In short, looking for fallacies such as the complex question is important.
3. How does Michael Moore's editing technique make the viewer react based upon the form of the interview?
Monday, September 17, 2007
Loaded Language: Powerful or Fallacy?
1. Unfortunately, I do not have a question to answer this week, but I will next week.
2. This week the topic of choice was on Loaded Language. I personally feel that loaded language is moving and persuasive, but it is different for each individual person. I look at fallacy in loaded language as fake propaganda. For example, when we had student elections in the fifth grade, kids would literally promise soda fountains and a water park. These promises were not true, but they were effective in getting people to vote for the person. The same is true in high school. Now, however, the fake promises are kept to minimum. What matters most to high schoolers includes dances specifically prom. Every campaign speech included something about making prom the best it has ever been. Other than this one promise, most people ride on the popularity card. Can they get people to vote for them through candy bribes, stickers, and other flashy objects. Loaded language in the political world is another step up. This is due to the fact that people have to be “politically correct”. I used to care, but now I think why it matters what you call it, it still exists. For example, Shakespeare once said “A rose by any other name would smell as sweet.” Hey as long as it is sweet, I don’t care what it is called. The point is to make people see either bad or good images. When I think nationalism, I think Red, white, and blue. I think cheering in the streets, and all other symbols of loyalty to one’s country. When I think gang, I think of people getting shot, and random fights on the street. The truth of the matter is that everyone comes with their own baggage and predisposition, so loaded language is not fallacy or powerful. The words are simple black on white. It is up to the individual as to what colors and images fill the lines.
3. My question to answer for next week is: What are the natural predisposition companies have on why and how consumers buy? And with this information, how do they market their product?
2. This week the topic of choice was on Loaded Language. I personally feel that loaded language is moving and persuasive, but it is different for each individual person. I look at fallacy in loaded language as fake propaganda. For example, when we had student elections in the fifth grade, kids would literally promise soda fountains and a water park. These promises were not true, but they were effective in getting people to vote for the person. The same is true in high school. Now, however, the fake promises are kept to minimum. What matters most to high schoolers includes dances specifically prom. Every campaign speech included something about making prom the best it has ever been. Other than this one promise, most people ride on the popularity card. Can they get people to vote for them through candy bribes, stickers, and other flashy objects. Loaded language in the political world is another step up. This is due to the fact that people have to be “politically correct”. I used to care, but now I think why it matters what you call it, it still exists. For example, Shakespeare once said “A rose by any other name would smell as sweet.” Hey as long as it is sweet, I don’t care what it is called. The point is to make people see either bad or good images. When I think nationalism, I think Red, white, and blue. I think cheering in the streets, and all other symbols of loyalty to one’s country. When I think gang, I think of people getting shot, and random fights on the street. The truth of the matter is that everyone comes with their own baggage and predisposition, so loaded language is not fallacy or powerful. The words are simple black on white. It is up to the individual as to what colors and images fill the lines.
3. My question to answer for next week is: What are the natural predisposition companies have on why and how consumers buy? And with this information, how do they market their product?
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)