1. One example of a controversial election would be that of Nigeria in 2007. The president was inaugurated whilst opposition parties continued to rally for a new election. There were three main parties. And the vice president of the predecessor contested as well. Unfortunately, fraud charges were brought up against the former VP and he was not allowed to run. This was the start of an election where the minority won and everyone was not happy just like the 2000 Gore- Bush election.
2. This week we finished Michael Moore hates America. The film used Michel Moore’s techniques against Michael Moore. The maker of the film Mike Wilson tried and failed. It just did not have the same appeal and convincing “facts” that Michel Moore does. He also seemed like a bit of a wuss because whenever he used a fallacy and tricked someone he would go back and apologize. I feel that was completely unnecessary. He is making a documentary not trying to show that he is not a sinner and won’t go to hell. I felt he was spineless and the people he chose for interviews were honest but more for the weak at heart. It showed me how Michael Moore is good at what he does, and people should not attempt to imitate him.
3. My question for next week is out of a hundred people, how many think they can do what Michael Moore does?
Michael Moore Hates America Questions 1-11
1. Mike Wilson uses the techniques: phantom questioning, and not completely informing his interviewees of what he is asking.
2. The style is similar because he tries to use music to portray a mood, and he uses images to provoke a mood and then to blame someone for it (Michael Moore). He is trying to build a case against Michael More as Michael Moore tries to build a case against George Bush in his documentaries.
3.Wilson dealt with trying to make sure he was ethical all the time and that he did not fall into the trap of being like Moore. He found this difficult and found that he had to explain himself a lot.
4. Michael Moore didn’t lie outright but the conclusions he draws stem from truth although they are twisted.
5. It is not ethical to lie, but sometimes in the heat of the moment someone can say something they do not truly mean. An apology or explanation is always nice, but who will explain everything they say or do. There is not enough time, and the world goes on.
6. He means that a documentary only provides one side of an argument, and therefore a person is lying because they do not present all the facts. All documentaries are not lies. Those on an objective subject like the mating habits of an amoeba do not spark controversy but a topic like a presidential election will always be under scrutiny because it affects so many people. To keep a documentary honest, a person must show everything A-Z on a topic. Anything less would mean cheating the audience.
7. A filmmaker crosses that line when he uses is own viewpoint to twist the words of other. To take someone’s opinion and distort it is to take away another’s identity and original thought and that is illegal.
8.He means that one should be afraid of becoming what you always feared because at times that is the only way. Basically, he is showing how Michael Moore may have done these things and now Mike Wilson is doing the same. Mike Wilson should be afraid because he is doing exactly what he said he would not.
9.Well, Michael Moore said he was born in this town called Flint when he was actually raised somewhere else. And he references this in all of his documentaries. To show how much of a liar Michael Moore is Wilson sets out to show that Michael Moore is from another town and he does.
10.Flint is portrayed as a small somewhat destitute town in Moore’s films and is seen as completely run down in Wilson’s film.
11.Mike Wilson’s theme is to prove Michael Moore wrong and use his techniques without lying or using fallacies.
Tuesday, January 1, 2008
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
No comments:
Post a Comment